John McLaughlin
Issue one - The Fall of Constantine.
[McLaughlin narrates over footage of Constantine and Bo's performances]
Last week on On American Idol, laid-back long-haired rocker Bo Bice was once
again the very manifestation of confidence and charisma, his trademark stage-prowling,
deft and deliberate mic stand manuevers and outrageous ensemble - which incuded
a sixties-style dashiki and wrap-around shades - won him a standing
ovation from the audience at the conclusion of his rendition of I Don't Want to Be, and garnered high praise from all three Idol judges, with the only remotely negative remark
coming from AI's own nattering nabob of negativity, Simon Cowell, whose
advice to Bice was simply, "Lose the Lenny Kravitz sunglasses."
Next, Constantine Maroulis strode boldly onto the AI stage, determined to knock
fellow rock and roller Bice out of the competition once and for all. But it
was not to be. The young Maroulis' glam rock glances - ala Bowie circa 1978
- couldn't disguise the fact that his own torpidity was turning a tractable
tune - Nickleback's How you Remind Me - into a mangled mass of missed
melodies that would ultimately fail to energize even his own base - the fawning fourteen and
fifteen-year old female followers who had up until that point dedicated themselves
to diligently dialing his designated number at the close of every show.
The following night, Idol fans from all over the globe and all sides of the
political spectrum were shocked to hear these words from the inimitable and
flamboyant Ryan Seacrest:
[Shot of Ryan Seacrest on the AI stage]
Ryan Seacrest
Constantine Maroulis...you're going home tonight.
John McLaughlin
Question: Are you surprised that Maroulis - without question a heartthrob unmatched
since since the days David Cassidy graced lunchboxes from coast to coast - was
voted off of the show? Pat Buchanan.
Pat Buchanan
No I am not, John, and I must point out that the entire premise of your opening
segment was flawed...
John McLaughlin
Flawed?? Are you challenging my expert analysis of last week's show?
Pat Buchanan
I am, if for no other reason than the fact that you completely ignored Carrie
and Anthony...
John McLaughlin
Come now. Are you, Pat Buchanan, disputing my earlier prediction that 2005 will
be the year of the rock and roller on American Idol?
Pat Buchanan
I am indeed, John. Look, you've got two young kids on
this show, this American Idol, whose life stories are shining examples of the American dream. This Anthony comes from a family of immigrants - legal immigrants, mind you...
Eleanor Clift
Oh, PLEASE!
John McLaughlin
Let him finish, Eleanor.
Pat Buchanan
At one time they didn't think the kid would ever be able to sing at all, then
he ends up in the top ten. Then you've got this girl, Carrie - she lives on
a farm, she's from a very wholesome, conservative family...
Eleanor Clift
Excuse me! Excuse me! Are you telling me that you can tell these people are
conservative just because they live on a farm?
Pat Buchanan [Chuckling]
Well what do you think? You think they get up every day, go out and milk
the cows and talk about how 13-year old girls ought to be allowed to have abortions
without their parents being involved?
Eleanor Clift
I think what they probably talk about when they're sitting around their
kitchen table...
Tony Blankley
Here we go with the kitchen table.
Eleanor Clift
Excuse me, I'm speaking! As I was saying, I think what they probably
talk about when they're sitting around their kitchen table is whether or not
Bush is going to bankrupt social security...
John McLaughlin
Let's get back on topic here. Tony Blankley - your reaction to the unceremonious
booting of Constantine.
Tony Blankley
Well, I think what you've just presented is a non sequitur...
John McLaughlin
Moi?
Tony Blankley
Yes, because no one gets booted from the show, if their performances aren't
up to par they don't get the votes...
Eleanor Clift
Are you just going to gloss over the voting problems they had last year?
Tony Blankley
I'm not glossing over anything...
Eleanor Clift
You denied the problems in Florida in 2000, Ohio in 2004, and now you're going
to sit there and deny...
Mort Zuckerman
Eleanor's just mad because she wants that Scotty the hottie to win and he's
probably out this week.
Eleanor Clift
It's Scott the body, and he's got ten times as much talent as your little
farm girl!
Pat Buchanan
He's ten times bigger than she is!
[Mort, Tony and Pat are laughing]
John McLaughlin
All right, calm down. Eleanor, are you surprised that Maroulis was voted off
the show?
Eleanor Clift
No, because Scott has been absolutely smoking him week after week, so it was
just a matter of time before...
Tony Blankley
The guy has a criminal record, Eleanor.
Eleanor Clift
Excuse me! I didn't interrupt you, and I find it interesting that you're willing
to make excuses for Tom Delay's crooked pals in Texas, but when Scotty...
John McLaughlin
Let's not get off the subject. Mort Zuckerman, you're usually the voice of reason
in this group of overpaid orators, and yet you're strangely quiet tonight -
what have you to say about last week's result?
Mort Zuckerman
Well, I think we're overlooking something very important, and that's the Vonzell
factor.
John McLaughlin
Indeed?
Mort Zuckerman
Absolutely. She has shown amazing consistency week after week, and she's got
something going for her that the others don't seem to, and that is an innate
ability to choose songs that allow her to showcase her incredible vocal range,
but don't challenge her to the extent that she is commiting any crucial errors
during her performances.
John McLaughlin
Interesting observations, incorrect though they may be.
Issue two: Judge not lest ye be judged. This week, disturbing allegations of
favoritism and even fraternization have been leveled against the Idol judges,
with the most serious being aimed at AI's golden girl, Paula Abdul. A former
contestant, who may or may not have a tell-all book deal in the works, has made
claims of late-night trysts with the former cheerleader and pop star, and there
are rumors of damaging answering machine messages captured on tape.
Question: What effect, positive or negative, will these unsubstantiated rumors - should they be substantiated - have on the show as a whole? Pat Buchanan.
Pat Buchanan
This will have a devastating effect on the show, John.
John McLaughlin
Devastating, you say?
Pat Buchanan
Absolutely devastating. You've got this woman, this Abdul, hopping into bed
with these young men, from what I hear she's popping pills and chasing them
with liquor...
Eleanor Clift
That's just a rumor! You have no proof of that!
Pat Buchanan
All I'm saying is that people are tuning in to see a family show, they don't
want to see a modern-day version of The Graduate, with some forty-year old broad
flashing some leg and a record contract so she can get some young guy in the sack.
John McLaughlin
Eleanor Clift.
Eleanor Clift
Well, contrary to what grandpa here thinks, this will have no effect whatsoever
on the show. Paula Abdul is loved by many people...
Pat Buchanan
Yeah, that's the problem!
[Everyone but Eleanor laughs]
John McLaughlin
Mort Zuckerman.
Mort Zuckerman
I'd like to reserve judgment, but I'm inclined to say that, should any of these
charges be substantiated, there may be a five to seven point drop in the ratings.
John McLaughlin
You'd be hard-pressed to find a more dispassionate and antiseptic piece of analysis.
Tony Blankley!
Tony Blankley
There will be little to no effect on the show.
John McLaughlin
Tony is correct, there will be little effect, if any, on the show's popularity
or ratings.
Exit question - on a probability scale of zero to 10, zero meaning zero probability,
10 meaning metaphysical certitiude, what is the probability that Scott will
be eliminated this week? Pat Buchanan.
Pat Buchanan
Nine - he's trying to be a crooner, and he's not showcasing his upper range.
John McLaughlin
Eleanor!
Eleanor Clift
Zero.
John McLaughlin
Zero you say?
Eleanor Clift
Zero - it's Scotty the body all the way.
John McLaughlin
A bold prediction indeed. Mor-ton!
Mort Zuckerman
Tough call, but considering he's been in the bottom three so often lately I'll
have to say 8.3.
John McLaughlin
Tony Blankley!
Tony Blankley
9.5 - he's toast.
John McLaughlin
The correct answer is ten, his demise is a metaphysical certitude. Be sure to
tune in next week, as The Apprentice is approaching critical mass. Go Bo! Bye-bye.